Israelis protest Loyalty Oath.

In Israel there was a huge rally this weekend. In Tel Aviv on Saturday night thousands gathered against proposed legislation there to create a loyalty oath to the state of Israel.  This is aimed at making life uncomfortable for all those who are not Jewish.  Read the Haaretz account. The oath would have all non-Jews (primarily read: ARAB) affirm loyalty to the Jewish state. This was part of a promise that Benjamin Netanyahu made to Avigdor Lieberman of the Israel Beiteynu party to form his coalition government. Lieberman has been at the heart of several controversial issues regarding Arabs in Israel and well as liberal Jews. Lieberman has long advocated an idea of “transfer”.  Literally to transfer Arab citizens of Israel to Palestinian territories.  And now his advocacy of this loyalty oath is a continuation of this policy.

The gist of the legislation is that if you cannot uphold the Jewish ideal of the state of Israel you would be denied citizenship.  This puts the bind on Israeli Arab citizens from the start.  Israel does allow non-Jews to live in Israel and to be citizens.  This loyalty oath would create even further divisions and inflame an already difficult and sensitive situation. But this is Lieberman’s modus operandi.  He likes stirring the pot.  And sadly, he is in a political position to bring continued harm  by stirring the pot.

The Central Conference of American Rabbis, the largest and oldest association of Rabbis in North America stated recently on the topic of the loyalty oath; “It would turn Israel into the very kind of country which historically Jews themselves have rightly cursed for their unequal treatment of non-Christians and non-Muslims.”

The Knesset, Israel’s Parliament, and the government officials can’t really believe that this kind of legislation will help move the peace process along.  I believe in a Jewish democratic Israel.  But loyalty oaths do not make for good democracy of any kind.

If I had been in Tel Aviv Saturday night I would have been at this protest.

2 thoughts on “Israelis protest Loyalty Oath.

  1. Your description is not 100% accurate. The people who would have to take the oath are new non-Jewish people who want to be citizens of Israel.

    What is wrong with having naturalized citizens take an oath to their new country? This is a requirement in America and other countries, isn’t it? And Israel IS a Jewish, democratic state – what is the problem with making people affirm this, as they wish to become citizens.

    Regarding the concept of transfer: is it alright that Jews are transferred out of Gaza, and potentially out of Judea/Samaria? The accusation of Israel acting is a racist manner is unfair. The true racists are those who believe that Jews should not be allowed to live in any future Palestinian state.

    There has alwasy been Arabs – Muslims and Christians – as citizens of Israel. The Christians in the PA areas are discriminsted against; women are treated as second class citizens and even foreign women have been forced to become wives (this is a documented fact); and being a Jew in a PA controlled area will lead you to be lynched.

    The beauty of Israel is that such demonstrations are possible and occur. At this time, it is safe to say that the majority of Israelis are for this loyalty oath, and do wish it to be expanded. For example, for members of the Knesset, which has members who are actively pursuing the destruction of the Jewish state. Would America tolerate any senators who are active members of Al Qaeda?

    Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s